The Unlikely Baker

Easy and Delicious Recipes for the Home Baker!

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk (Video)

by 120 Comments [This site contains affiliate links. As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. See Terms of Use for more information.]

Easy Meyer lemon pie with condensed milk – perfectly sweet and tangy, luxuriously smooth and silky. Every bite of this creamy Meyer lemon pie is a burst of bright and vibrant citrus flavour. Rich and so refreshing, it’s awesome with tea or as an end to a lovely meal.

(Love Meyer lemons? Me too! Check out these delicious Meyer lemon recipes that’s sure to chase those winter blues away – luxurious limoncello cupcakes topped with limoncello cream cheese frosting and this refreshing lemon layer cake with homemade Meyer lemon curd sandwiched in between – perfect for Easter!)

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk (Video)

With words like “polar vortex”, “bitter cold” and “extreme cold weather alerts” in fashion once more, I am arming myself with the best cure for winter blues that I know – lemons, of course!

Lemons (and other citrus fruits) are at their best in the winter and are really one of the few things I like about the season. They’re sunshine on a plate! Like this easy Meyer lemon pie.

What are Meyer lemons?

Meyer lemons are a cross between regular lemons and mandarin oranges. They are juicy, less acidic and sweeter.

Unlike normal lemons, which are available all year, Meyer lemons only appear in shelves between November and March. Sometimes the window is even smaller than that. So as soon as I see them, I grab a bag (ok, two) and go on a Meyer lemon frenzy.

How to make easy Meyer lemon pie with condensed milk

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk (Video)

And Meyer lemons shine in this recipe for Meyer lemon pie. It’s so easy to make too!

Just stir sweetened condensed milk, sour cream, Meyer lemon juice and Meyer lemon zest until combined. If you want the smoothest, creamiest pie filling, you have the option to sift your mixture through a fine mesh sieve into your pie dish.

Bake for 20 minutes, chill in the fridge until it’s set and you’re done! Egg-free and done in a flash (this is similar to my recipe for perfect – and also eggless – key lime pie). It’s really the easiest lemon pie ever.

How to make coconut cookie graham cracker crust

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk (Video)

These kinds of pie recipes usually have a graham cracker crust because they’re so great together. However, since it worked so well in my best lemon cheesecake recipe (have you tried it? So good!), I did a similar crust for this pie – graham crackers and coconut.

That flavour profile just works so well with the lemony filling. Think of it as your favourite graham cracker crust, but better!

You simply add sweetened shredded coconut and omit the sugar. The combination of the Meyer lemon pie filling and the coconut cookie crust is just crazy delicious.

It’s become my favourite crust to make and I’ve used it several times on TUB, like in these mouth-watering lime bars.

Ingredients you need for this Meyer lemon pie recipe

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk (Video)

The ingredients you need to make this scrumptious lemon dessert are pretty straightforward. For the coconut cookie graham cracker crust, you would need:

For the Meyer lemon pie filling, you would need:

  • Sweetened condensed milk
  • Sour cream
  • Meyer lemon juice and zest (and yes, you can use regular lemons if you can’t find Meyer lemons)

All these ingredients together is the perfect balance between sweet and tangy. And did I mention it was so creamy? It melts in your mouth. Just wonderful!

I love topping the pie with lemon whipped cream (to-die for) and more toasted shredded coconut.

Tools you need to make this easy Meyer lemon pie

True to its name, making this pie is easy peasy (watch the video if you don’t believe me!). No special tools required. Just bowls, a spoon to stir with and a 9-inch pie dish.

Of course, to prep, the following would be extremely helpful as well:

So how about it? Let’s get through these last few weeks (or months) of winter together with this creamy Meyer lemon pie with condensed milk. It really is a burst of sunshine on a gloomy winter day!

More lemon dessert recipes

If you love lemon as much as I do, you’d love these lemon desserts. Perfectly sweet and tangy, just how we lemon lovers like it!

Every lemon fan should have a recipe for everybody’s favourite lemon dessert – lemon bars set on a delicious shortbread crust.

Lemon Bars with Shortbread Crust

This sweet and salty, soft and moist lemon ricotta pound cake is sure to win hearts too.

Meyer Lemon Ricotta Pound Cake

And lemme share a secret: I love lemons so much I have a whole category dedicated to just lemon recipes. Enjoy!

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk (Video)

Easy Meyer Lemon Pie with Condensed Milk

Meyer lemon pie with condensed milk - perfectly sweet and tangy, luxuriously smooth and silky. With step-by-step video.
5 from 15 votes
Print Pin Rate
Course: Dessert
Cuisine: North American
Keyword: Easter, Mother's Day, Spring, Winter
Prep Time: 30 mins
Cook Time: 20 mins
Chilling Time: 8 hrs
Total Time: 8 hrs 50 mins
Servings: 8 people
Calories: 204kcal
Author: Jolina

Ingredients

For the Crust:

  • 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs
  • 1/2 cup sweetened shredded coconut
  • 6 tbsp unsalted butter melted and cooled slightly
  • 1/8 tsp salt see notes

For the Filling:

  • 2 10-oz cans sweetened condensed milk
  • 1/2 cup sour cream
  • 3/4 cup fresh Meyer lemon juice see notes
  • Meyer lemon zest add all the zest from lemons you use

Optional Toppings:

  • Lemon whipped cream see notes
  • Toasted shredded coconut
US Customary - Metric

Instructions

  • Preheat oven to 350F.
  • In a small bowl, combine 1 1/2 cups graham cracker crumbs, 1/2 cup sweetened shredded coconut, 6 tablespoons melted butter and 1/8 teaspoon salt. Stir until evenly moist. Press onto the bottom and up the sides of a 9-inch pie dish. Set aside.
  • In a large bowl, stir 2 cans sweetened condensed milk, 1/2 cup sour cream, 3/4 cup lemon juice and lemon zest until thoroughly combined.
  • Optional: To ensure the smoothest filling, sift your filling into your pie dish through a fine mesh sieve to get rid of lumps (see notes).
  • Bake for about 20 minutes or until the sides are starting to firm up but the middle is still a little jiggly (not soupy). Allow to cool slightly before chilling in the fridge so it can set completely, preferably overnight.
  • Serve with lemon whipped cream and toasted shredded coconut.

Video

Notes

  1. If you watch the video, you'll notice I did not put salt in the mixture. I actually forgot while filming but I added it in later.
  2. You can substitute regular lemons. Your pie will just be slightly tarter.
  3. If you opt to strain the mixture, note that you'll likely strain away most of the lemon zest. To achieve a more lemony flavour, skip the straining so that your pie filling has all the zest in it. Don't worry, it will still be super creamy!
  4. To make lemon whipped cream, just add lemon zest to this recipe for homemade whipped cream.
Tried this recipe?Tag @iamtheunlikelybaker or use hashtag #iamtheunlikelybaker!

Happy baking!

Did you make this easy Meyer lemon pie with condensed milk? I’d love to hear from you in the comments section below.

If you like pies but not as big a fan of lemon as I am (but why?), you’ll find other pie recipes here.

And let’s get social! Find me on Facebook, Pinterest, Instagram, Twitter and Flipboard.

BTW just a friendly reminder: Valentine’s Day is around the corner! Planning to surprise someone with a really special breakfast? Check out this ultimate list of breakfast ideas. You’re sure to find a recipe here your loved one would love!


(This post was updated on 01 February 2019.)

Reader Interactions

Comments


  1. Our department celebrated “Pi Day” this week with a pie baking contest. While not much of a baker, at the last minute I decided to participate and did a quick internet search two days before and came across this recipe. Given the short time frame, I had zero time to search for Meyer lemons and had to use regular lemons. The results were sensational and much to my surprise your pie won “Most Appealing” and “Best Tasting!” People just marveled over the designs on the top! Thank you sooo much – you’ve made a subscriber out of me! Christine

    Reply

    • That’s fantastic Christine!! So awesome 🙂 Hope this is the beginning of a fun and delicious baking adventure for you. And thanks for subscribing 🙂

      Reply


  2. Oh, My! This brings back so many memories. We use to do something similar with lemonade or limeade. Those pies were so good. My MIL was the one who introduced me to this method. I’d completely forgotten about it and how good it was. I’m going to have to make this. Thank you for the reminder.

    Reply


  3. I love lemon anything but I’m the only one in the family. So when I make a lemon dessert, it’s all for me..!! I never complain. Can’t wait to try this

    Reply


  5. I love Meyer lemons! They have such a subtle but unique taste. I’ll have to give this a try sometime because my hubby would LOVE it! You make it look so easy!

    Reply


  6. My grandson has asked for a LEMON PIE for his birthday!! He is going to be 7!! This looks like it just might be the one. Sounds delicious…looks amazing. I LOVE Meyer lemons and wish they were available all year.

    Reply

    • Awesome choice! Though a little unusual for a 7-year old…I think you might have a little foodie in your hands 🙂 Hope the little guy likes it! PS: I hope Meyer lemons were available all year too…

      Reply

  7. Jolina, please clarify an issue for me. On the ingredients on your Creamy Meyer Lemon pie, you show two 10oz cans of the sweetened evaporated milk. I don’t find any 10 oz cans, only 14 oz. which is what you show in your supplies. On the instructions, you say to use 2 cans of the sweetened evaporated milk. Are you measuring out 20 oz or are you using two full cans that would equal 28 oz?

    Reply

    • Hi Ronda, I use 2 300-ml cans, which are the sizes available here. That converts to roughly 10-oz per can. If you can only get 10-oz cans there, I suggest to weigh 20 oz/600 ml for this recipe. Using 2 full 14-oz cans is going to be too sweet and your pie may not set properly. Hope this helps!

      Reply


  8. Omg this lemon pie is what my dreams are made of! I too looooooooove lemon!

    This recipe is so easy to make and is absolutely delicious! I just made it to take to my in-laws for Easter and there was a little extra filling leftover so I put it in a ramekin so I could try it. OMG amazing!! I used a cheater graham cracker crust and up’d the lemon juice to about 1c. YUM!!! Thanks for the recipe!!

    Reply


  9. Hey, Jolina! Just wanted to say we made this recipe again this weekend. Hehehe, it’s so good! In fact, we made it Sunday and it was gone by Monday evening. I hope you have a great day, Jolina!

    Reply

    • Aw that made my day! 🙂 You guys are the best. Food that disappears is a great sign isn’t it?? Have a wonderful day too!

      Reply

  10. I love how much you love Meyer lemons! I’ve only used once so far but they are much better flavor than regular. I haven’t seem them in my grocery stores much, I wonder why? There’s so many recipes to choose from if I do find some!

    Reply

    • Hi Mindy! I know they’re only available certain months of the year and it differs depending where you are. Meyer lemons are no longer available where I am (boo!) but I think in certain states (California maybe?) they’re available until May. If you do find some, give it a try. They are delightful 🙂

      Reply

    • Thanks Jennifer. It really depends on the lemons you get. And it’s really not the size too eh? Big doesn’t always mean juicy because it might sometimes be just pulp. I’d say 4 and you should be OK. Having extra is a happy problem 🙂 Hope you like it! Would love to hear how it goes.

      Reply

  12. Wow this looks absolutely amazing! I have been obsessed with all things lemon lately. I can’t wait to wow all my friends and family with this amazing recipe! It makes me crave warm summer days! Lovely presentation.

    Reply

    • I have been on a lemon craze lately too! And yes, this pie gives me hope that winter will end too. Someday! Hope you like it Destiny.

      Reply

  16. Lemon is one of my favorite flavors! It makes me think of summer and in the middle of February, I’m desperate for those days! I think the coconut crust is a brilliant flavor combination too!

    Reply

    • Me too and yes, it makes me think winter will end…someday! LOL! The coconut crust works beautifully here, if I say so myself 🙂 Hope you get to try the pie soon Jessica!

      Reply

  18. My goodness I am in love with that lemon pie right away, it looks absolutely delicious & mouth watering. The pictures are so inviting that I would love to give it a try right away!

    Reply


  19. Made it yesterday night, it came out quite tasty. Definitely in the “make again” category. Thank you so much jolina for sharing this.

    Reply

  25. This looks delicious!

    Lemon-flavored desserts are some of my absolute favorites so I’m 100% going to have to try this out.

    Reply

  26. I just picked up a bag of meyer lemons at the store and wasn’t sure what to make with them. Thanks for the inspiration – this looks amazing, especially the coconut crust!

    Reply

  27. I haven’t done much with Meyer Lemons this season! I really need to get my act together before they’re gone next month! This looks absolutely amazing, it sure would cheer up my winter blues!

    Reply

    • It definitely cheers mine up 🙂 And I usually freeze the juice and zest of Meyer lemons so I have my supply when they’re gone.

      Reply

  30. I would love to try this pie! Lemon is one of the best flavors. It’s so citrusy and fresh. I don’t think we have Meyer lemons where I live,, though. At least I don’t recall seeing any. They sound lovely, so I’ll be on the lookout.

    Reply

    • Truth be told, I always pick lemon desserts over chocolate desserts. They’re just wonderful aren’t they? Hope you find Meyer lemons! If not, regular lemons are great too 🙂

      Reply


      • So, I finally found Meyer lemons and made this pie over the weekend. I substituted a gluten-free pie crust for the graham cracker crust, and the entire pie was gone in less than 2 days! It was amazing and so creamy and smooth. Great recipe! Will definitely be making it again.

        Reply

        • Awesome! Glad you found Meyer lemons, they are one of my favourite things 🙂 I’m happy you like the pie Kimberly! It would be perfect for summer too (though no more Meyer lemons then, regular lemons would do just fine I think!)

          Reply

  31. I am not a big fan of pie. But this recipe sounds very good. At least I can make this to my daughter who love lemon pie:)

    Reply

  32. The lemon looks awesome and just the way I like, delicate and sophisticated. My son loves lemon flavored everything. He will be very happy to see this recipe.

    Reply

  33. This pie is too gorgeous to eat and I will find it hard to eat such a beauty! However, I am sure my sugar cravings will get the better of me for sure! Love it!!!

    Reply

  34. This looks delicious! I make a cheesecake with Meyer lemons when I can find them, sometimes they’re hard to find around me.

    Reply

  36. Wow! all of these desserts look delicious. I’m not a big fan of lemon flavor but id make this for a get together.

    Reply

  38. That is the most beautiful pie!! I am extremely envious of your piping skills! And your recipe sounds so delicious. I first came across Meyer lemons when we lived in the US for a few years. Since, returning to Switzerland, they are nowhere to be found here, although I was lucky to find a Meyer lemon tree last year and I have been doing my best to keep it alive. There are three small fruits which are starting to ripen, and I’m already thinking of how to put them to good use, especially since it will be another year before I will have anymore (fingers crossed). Thanks for the delicious recipe!

    Reply

    • Now you are just making me jealous of your little tree! It sounds lovely. Thanks Thanh, I hope you get to make this pie and I hope you like it…the recipe works with regular lemons too if you have something else in mind for your Meyer lemons 🙂

      Reply

  42. We will not be getting an early spring so I must make this wonderful and delicious pie because lemon makes me happy! Looks so beautiful and decadent!!

    Reply

  43. You had me at “Coconut Cookie Crust!” I am crazy for coconut. Absolutely obsessed. In fact, I could probably eat the crust alone!

    Reply

  44. Oh my your decorating on this is so pretty! I love the idea of the coconut crust, so delicious. Mine would NEVER turn out like this I am certain but I’d like to try it. I love a lemon dessert!

    Reply

  46. Growing up Lemon Icebox Pie was my favorite and it was so quick to make! This reminds me of that, just fancier! Will be trying this in the near future!!

    Reply

  47. I hope you’ve saved me slice! I don’t know what I’m drooling over more- the coconut graham cracker crust or the Meyer lemon filling! It all looks so amazing!!

    Reply

    • Thanks Erica! I love the combination of lemon and coconut too. Hope you get to make this pie one day soon and I hope you like it! 🙂

      Reply


  50. Another delicious treat! I can clearly see your love for Meyer lemon…I’m going to start trying Meyer lemons.

    Reply

  52. That pie looks amazing! I actually never tried lemon pie before but the recepie looks so easy I am tempted to try it now 🙂

    Reply

  54. My husband loves lemon meringue pie. He’s always happy to try new lemon based recipes so I’ll be trying this out soon!

    Reply


  55. Love lemon and I love coconut. Would you believe that I’m in Florida and I find Meyer lemons hard to find? I know it sounds crazy but I think they send all of them to Canada and there’s a person up there that grabs all of the bags. You wouldn’t happen to know her, would you? 🙂 Seriously, though, I am telling the truth about finding the lemons down here. This recipe sounds fantastic. I’m pinning!

    Reply

    • HAHAHAHA this almost made me fall off my chair laughing Marisa. And no, I have NO IDEA what you are talking about lol. Hope you do get your hands on some Meyer lemons. If not, regular lemons work too 🙂 Thanks for the pin!

      Reply

  57. This pie looks stunning! I’ve never tried meyer lemons but I think I need to. I always love recipes that incorporate a little tangy flavor!

    Reply

  60. I agree with you! Coconut and lemon are such a great pairing and lemons have an uplifting effect! This is definitely a dreamy pie, beautiful and oh so delicious!

    Reply

  61. Jolina, that pie sounds super decadent! I’m such a fan of using condensed milk in baked goods. I know it’s super sweet, but the sour cream and lemon in this recipe will no doubt cut out the sweetness quite a bit. For toppings, I think I’d want both the frosting and the coconut. 🙂

    Reply

    • Hey Byron! Condensed milk is like the national dairy in the Philippines where I’m originally from lol. It’s like a magical ingredient! 🙂

      Reply

  62. Is there anything better then meyer lemons? Only when they’re in a delicious pie like this! I’m in luscious lemon Heaven. I love lemon desserts and this is a beauty. This pie would brighten up even the gloomiest of Winter days!

    Reply

    • Hi Megan! I love lemon desserts too. I might get hate mail for saying this but I like it better than chocolate lol!! Meyer lemons are just lovely. Hope winter is not too gloomy where you are.

      Reply

  63. Lol- our Punxsutawney Phil said 6 more weeks of winter! Crazy groundhog! (Although.. doesn’t that mean spring will come in March? Shocking. Hahaha)
    This sounds AMAZING.. I just found myer lemons at the store and need something to use them in!

    Reply

    • HAHAHA all these famous groundhogs need to meet THEN make the announcement eh?? And how awesome are their names? Too funny. I go a little nuts when I see Meyer lemons TBH. I know I still have some at home but I can’t resist buying more lol. I need a Meyer lemon intervention.

      Reply

  64. Yum! Lemon Pie’s are my all time favorite dessert. My grandmother could make the best pie. Your recipe sounds amazing and it is on my to make list.

    Reply

  65. I got a bag of Meyer lemon last week too and made a babka. Love the flavor and citrus is my favorite dessert flavor! Love the creamy filling, the photo itself makes my mouth cold and lemony!

    Reply

    • You’re becoming a really good baker Suchi! I’d love some of that lemony babka 🙂 And yes, Meyer lemons are pretty awesome aren’t they? BTW how’s everything? Are you guys finally done with the move? Hope everything’s going great!

      Reply

      • Thanks Jolina! No not yet, we are waiting for Jay”s job but most tentative is April 1. I will be going little earlier for apartment and stuff.

        Reply

  66. OMG! This looks amaze balls, Jolina! Me and lemon? LOVE IT!! I don’t know about that early spring as I look outside and the snowstorm we are having today, but I do know that I would devour this pie in 10 seconds flat. Pinned! P.S. I had no idea about two groundhogs….that’s too funny 😀

    Reply

    • Hi Dawn! I know me too, we’re under an extreme weather alert again today haha. Oh well. We have lemons! Aren’t they just wonderful?? 🙂 We’re so biased lol. Thanks for the pin!

      Reply

Trackbacks

Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *